Document fraud detection

Detect a fake medical fee note

Osteopathy, dental care, optics, psychology: fee notes and care invoices trigger reimbursements from health insurers. An inflated amount or a treatment that never took place is paid out directly. Docusan checks these documents as soon as they are received.

Fee note, invoice, care sheet: what is the difference in France?

A French care sheet, the feuille de soins, is the proof of medical expenses sent to the national health insurance, usually electronically with the patient’s Vitale card. A fee note or care invoice, by contrast, is given to the patient to show what they paid. It becomes the key document when social security does not cover the treatment: some top-up health contracts reimburse osteopathy, for example, and non-contracted psychologists set their own unreimbursed rates.

The format varies from one practice to another. A note usually shows the practitioner and their identifiers, the patient, the date and nature of the treatment, the amount and how it was paid. It is not always issued: for French doctors, a receipt is only mandatory for cash payments, and an electronic care sheet serves as both bill and receipt. The patient can ask for a copy.

For doctors, the French code of medical ethics bans any fraud, abusive coding or inaccurate statement of fees received and treatment given (article R4127-29 of the Public Health Code, in French).

What you can check against official sources

  • The practitioner: the RPPS is now France’s national register of health professionals, including osteopaths, chiropractors, psychologists, psychotherapists and opticians. Numbers appear in the Annuaire Santé, its public directory. Elsewhere, look for the equivalent national register.
  • The business: the Annuaire des entreprises, the French government’s company directory, lets you check the entity and its address. When a practitioner issues an invoice, its contents are regulated: a unique number in a chronological sequence, dates, a SIREN company number.
  • The rate: French practitioners must display their rates and their sector. When they charge above the standard rate, prior written information is required from €70: it describes the treatment, the fees and the part covered, and can be compared with the note.
  • VAT: in France, therapeutic care by the listed professions is exempt from VAT. VAT on an ordinary session with one of those professions calls for a question, whereas it is normal for purely cosmetic procedures or a sophrologist.

These checks show that the practitioner exists, not that the treatment took place: a real number can appear on a note they never issued.

In doubt about a document?

Analyze it for free: Docusan flags the anomalies and locates them on the document.

Try it for free

How to spot a fake medical bill: a 6-step method

  1. Identify the practitioner

    Find them in the official directory, then compare the printed address and number. An old French ADELI number proves nothing: those identifiers are now obsolete, but a practice may still use an old template.

  2. Match the treatment to the profession

    Does the billed treatment belong to this profession, and is its description precise enough to understand? Does the date fall within the period covered by the policy? A vague, generic description deserves a question.

  3. Check the amounts

    Do the lines add up, and does the amount paid match the total? A high rate is not an anomaly in itself where practitioners set their own rates: compare the note with others from the same practitioner instead.

  4. Cross-check with other documents

    When French social security reimburses the treatment, a care sheet exists, and its date and amount should agree. Compare the note with the prescription if there is one, and treat an equipment invoice as a document in its own right. For uncovered treatment, verifying the practitioner becomes the main check.

  5. Examine the file

    A PDF keeps traces: software used, dates, saved versions. Our free tool reads them in your browser, without sending anything, and our guide explains how to tell if a PDF was edited.

  6. Ask the practitioner to confirm

    Use their official contact details, never those printed on the note, and stick to facts: did they issue this note, on this date, for this amount? Ask nothing about the patient’s health.

Typical inconsistencies in a fake fee note

None of these signs is proof on its own; several together justify a closer check:

  • Numbering: numbers that repeat, or do not follow the timeline between two notes from the same practice.
  • Timeline: a series of sessions on unlikely dates, a note dated before the policy took effect.
  • Payment: a “paid” marking with no payment method, an amount that differs from the supporting statement.
  • Form: an amount in a different font or alignment, a blurred or crooked stamp, a signature strictly identical from one note to the next.
  • Portfolio: the same template across supposedly unconnected practitioners, notes that consistently land on the policy’s limit.

Psychologists, optics, hospitals: special cases

France’s Mon soutien psy scheme follows precise rules: 12 sessions per calendar year at €50 each, one per day, with a contracted psychologist. The national health insurance covers 60%, and the top-up insurer under a standard “responsible” contract 40%. Another rate under this scheme, or more sessions for no known reason, calls for an explanation.

Optics, dental care and hearing aids partly fall under France’s 100% Santé scheme. For optics, lenses are split into classes A and B, and a frame at €30 or less leaves nothing to pay. The invoice should therefore match the declared equipment and a prescription that is still valid.

A hospital stay ends with a document detailing the costs, the part covered and what remains to pay.

What to do if a fee note looks fake

Start by asking for the original document and, if needed, confirmation from the practitioner: a practice’s mistake or a high rate is not fraud. Keep a record of your check and restrict access to the file, as a fee note often reveals health data.

According to ALFA, the French association against insurance fraud, most contracts provide for loss of cover in the event of an intentional false statement, and the insurer can reclaim payments already made. It counts €294 million of identified fraud in personal insurance for the 2025 financial year, a figure that measures what its members detected, not the real extent of the problem.

Under French criminal law, article 441-1 punishes forgery and its use with three years in prison and a €45,000 fine, and article 313-1 punishes fraud with five years in prison and a €375,000 fine. What happens next is for your legal department. Our health insurance page shows these checks within the reimbursement workflow.

Checking fee notes as volumes grow

Checking every note by hand takes time, and the eye does not see everything: a carefully retouched amount can leave no visible trace. Docusan, a French document fraud detection service, analyzes the file you receive, as a PDF, scan or photo, and gives a verdict: No detection, Warning or Alert. The anomalies are located on the document, with a comment to understand them, and the decision always stays with your claims handlers.

Docusan does not contact the practitioner or query government databases: it complements the checks above and does not replace them. You can use it from the platform or integrate it into your management tool with its API, with the Enterprise plan. Documents are hosted in the European Union and are never used to train our models (security and privacy).

Sources

Typical frauds

The most common forgeries

01

Inflated amount

The amount of a genuine fee note is increased to obtain a reimbursement above the actual costs.

02

Fictitious or impersonated practitioner

The note is issued in the name of a practitioner who does not exist, or whose identity and numbers are used without their knowledge.

03

Fabricated note

A note is created from a template for a treatment that never took place.

Our detection approach

What Docusan analyzes

Four levels of analysis to spot forgeries, whether the document is a PDF, a scan or a photo.

01

Metadata

  • Missing metadata
  • Inconsistencies in the file properties
02

Pixel-level anomalies

  • AI-generated images, deepfakes
  • Inserted content (splicing, inpainting, copy-move…)
03

Structural anomalies

  • Edits and annotations
  • Recovery of previous versions
04

Customizable detectors

  • Consistency with document templates
  • Data cross-checking
  • Watchlists

Relevant industries

The result

What a report looks like

Each document gets a verdict: No detection, Warning or Alert. The anomalies are located on the document, with a comment to understand them.

Alert

  • Modified area of the document
  • Inconsistent file properties
  • A comment for each clue
Illustration with a fictitious document. The clues depend on the document analyzed.

FAQ

Your questions

How do you spot a fake medical bill?

Check that the practitioner exists in the official directory, that the treatment belongs to their profession, that the amounts add up and that the bill agrees with the other documents on file. Then examine the file itself. A single clue is not enough: what counts is how many there are.

How do you verify a bill for treatment that public insurance does not cover?

No care sheet can back it up, so the practitioner becomes the main check: look them up in the national register, review the treatment and dates, and ask them to confirm through their official contact details if doubt remains.

Is an old ADELI number on a French fee note suspicious?

Not necessarily. The RPPS has replaced ADELI, but a practice may still use an old template. Simply check that the practitioner appears in the Annuaire Santé at the same address.

Does a fee note replace a care sheet in France?

No. The care sheet is used for reimbursement by the national health insurance, while the fee note shows the patient, or their top-up insurer, what was paid. Both can exist for the same treatment.

Can Docusan automatically analyze every note received?

Yes. The Enterprise plan’s API integrates with your management tool: each document is analyzed upon receipt and its verdict is reported in real time.

Can the notes of a single policyholder be grouped?

Yes. Analyses can be grouped by folder, to review a set of documents together.

Which formats are accepted?

PDF, PNG, JPEG and TIFF files, scans and photos included, in any language. The checks depend on the file format.

Try it for free

High volumes?

Automate your checks

A subscription with included pages from the Pro plan; the API, dedicated infrastructure and customized detectors with the Enterprise plan.